I think a book has to be non-fiction if it’s going to be sold as non-fiction. I know: it’s a profound thought. If you’re writing a book about your life you need to recall all the conversations and events to the best of your ability. You should not make up that you’re multiracial or that you were adopted, if you’re white and still living in your biological parents’ house. That’s called realistic fiction, not a memoir. Certain obvious things, like that, we shouldn’t even have to ponder. There are some grey areas (like conversations), but I think if we try to get them as close to the truth as possible, it counts as a non-fiction memoir. Oh and saying you were in a gang, when in reality you only saw a movie about a gang is not as close to the truth as possible.
I do think we need genres as a reader or we would quickly get confused as to what’s real and what’s not. Our world is confusing enough, thank you. It helps you pick out the book you’re looking for. For instance, if you need to write a paper for forensics and you say some people died because of Voldemort, because the Harry Potter series was under non-fiction at the bookstore, you probably won’t get a good grade on that. It is important distinguish what is what. It helps the reader more than it hurts the author. Genres are necessary. There are too many books to know what each is about, or if you might be interested in reading it.
I agree that we need genres as a reader because people need to know if what they are reading is real or not.
ReplyDeleteI agree that non fiction books need to be as close to the truth as possible. Of course you have to make up dialogue and things like that, but as long as it doesn't stray away from the main story, it's fine.
ReplyDeleteWould you ever use lines between genres fully?
ReplyDeleteYes. I agree with everything you have said. Non-fiction is non-fiction. And it needs to be labled that way. And we do need lables because there are just so many books. We can't mix them all together because they are not all the same.
ReplyDeleteI think that people need top be smart enough to decipher what is real and not real when it comes to doing research. Everything in life can't be completely shelved and written. If Clorox Bleach was in the soup isle you wouldn't be like "Oh well I guess since it's here I'll drink it!"
ReplyDeleteI agree with Leah that people should be able to have some sort of knowledge to be able to tell the difference between a story that is non-fiction and a story that is fiction. I still think that there should be genre labels though, for the books that could honestly be placed in either genre if you didn't know which it was.
ReplyDeleteI think both can take a little embellishment, memoirs more than non-fiction. I really don't think anyone wants to know about all the facts in your life.
ReplyDelete